The essay approaches this specifically from a humanitarian context where Singer argues that wealthy individuals are morally bound to question the common intuition that physical distance and the means of using money reduces our moral obligation to help compared with the difference between the affluent nations and the poor nations Apr 28, · IELTS Writing Task 2/ IELTS Essay: You should spend about 40 minutes on this task. Some people say that rich nations should help poor countries with their basic needs like food and education while others oppose the idea and argue that the May 27, · This essay agrees that wealthy nations should help other nations that are in need. Firstly, it will help form a strong bond among nations. Secondly, poor nations are sometimes just caught up in the middle of the chaos for many reasons that render them their inability to
Famine, Affluence and Morality, by Peter Singer: Summary + Full Text · Giving What We Can
The promise of should wealthy nations help poor nations essay fair-trade movement is that coffee growers in poor nations will receive a higher price for coffee if it is produced in better working conditions with higher wages. Unfair prices: One of the most basic concepts in economics, remembered by Economics students long after they have forgotten everything else, is that prices are determined by the interaction of supply and demand.
If the world price cannot be changed by the farmer, then appealing to people to pay more than the world price is should wealthy nations help poor nations essay begging; it is asking for a charitable donation. It might raise a bit of money for a few growers, but will not change the world price.
The best long-term solution is for the small coffee grower to switch to another kind of crop where he or she can earn a living, or even to leave farming for another occupation altogether. Here is an analogy: suppose a man tries to earn a living by collecting used aluminum cans from trash bins and selling them to a recycling center. I work all day and only earn a few dollars. No, that would be foolish. But at this point we wish to point out that people can and do care for the natural world in many other ways than supporting fair-trade coffee.
The fair-trade movement is not necessary to care for nature in effective ways. Some success: Campaigns for fair-trade coffee, like all campaigns for charitable contributions, should wealthy nations help poor nations essay, do bring some help for the people to whom the contributions are given.
But that does not mean the benefits outweigh the harm that is done. It is also necessary to consider the harm that comes to all the other coffee growers in the world, who receive lower prices when the fair-trade movement increases production beyond what the world market demands, as indicated by the world price for coffee. In addition, the fair-trade movement keeps its coffee growers in a crop that can provide them with an adequate living only so long as they keep receiving these charitable contributions from others.
It discourages them from changing to another crop or another occupation where they could support themselves for a lifetime without depending on subsidies. In Fair Trade? Its Prospects as a Poverty Solution, economist Victor Claar identifies an economic harm that comes from an artificial increase of the price of some coffee above what the world market will bear that is, higher than the price set by world supply and demand.
Paying some growers a higher price than the world market price for coffee encourages them to grow more coffee than the market actually demands. Claar writes:. Thus, while there is too much coffee being grown relative to global demand in general, there is also not sufficient demand to purchase, at the fair trade price, all of the coffee being grown as fair trade coffee.
In both cases, there is simply too much coffee. The larger supply of coffee then depresses the price for other coffee growers that are not part of the fair-trade movement. Claar goes on to say that artificially raising the price for coffee only prolongs the problem of too much coffee on the world market:. If the fundamental problem with the coffee market is that prices are low because there is too much coffee, should wealthy nations help poor nations essay, then it would appear that the fair-trade movement may be making matters worse rather than better because it increases the incentives to grow more coffee.
The price premium in fair trade products is a form of charitable transfer, and there is evidently no harm in that. But the problem with it, as compared with just giving people the aid in other ways, is that it encourages recipients to stay doing what they are doing—producing coffee. They get charity as long as they stay producing the crops that have locked them into poverty. Charitable contributions to the poor are more efficiently given by other means, and such charitable transfers will never lead to a long-term solution for world poverty, or even for most growers of a single product, such as coffee.
In their chapter, Grudem and Asmus examine whether capitalism or human sin is to blame for the exploitation of poor countries. This post was previously published on Nov. Did you enjoy this article? You can help us to empower Christians to transform the world through their work. Support IFWE today. such charitable transfers will never lead to a long-term solution for world poverty, or even for most growers of a single product, such as coffee, should wealthy nations help poor nations essay.
We live in a world of exploding opportunities and growing challenges. New technologies are transforming our lives. Despite intermittent economic…. Contact Information. Skip to content. Economics Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Email Subscribe Print.
This is not fair to the farmers, who then cannot make any money growing coffee. Care for nature : Fair-trade coffee strives to be organic, bird-friendly, and shade-growth oriented. Some success : Thousands of fair-trade coffee growers have already been helped by this kind of program. However, those arguments are not as persuasive as they first appear. Is Our Helping Actually Hurting?
Claar writes: Thus, while there is too much coffee being grown relative to global demand in general, there is also not sufficient demand to purchase, at the fair trade price, all of the coffee being grown as fair trade coffee. Claar goes on to say that artificially raising the price for coffee only prolongs the problem of too much coffee on the world market: If the fundamental problem with the coffee market is that prices are low because there is too much coffee, then it would appear that the fair-trade movement may be making matters worse rather than better because it increases the incentives to grow more coffee.
Wayne Grudem Wayne Grudem is currently research professor of theology and biblical studies at Phoenix Seminary. He has published over twenty books, including The Poverty of Nations: A Sustainable Solution, should wealthy nations help poor nations essay. InGrudem served as the general editor for the ESV Study Bible. All rights reserved.
For reprint permissions, contact info should wealthy nations help poor nations essay. Receive IFWE's content right in your inbox. Further readings on Economics Anne Bradley 5 minute read. Read More. Economics Do Economic Liberties Benefit the Should wealthy nations help poor nations essay the Most? By: Doug Bandow 6 minute read. Salutation Please select Father Rev.
First Name. Last Name. Email Address. ZIP Code. Country Please select Occupation Please select Which publications would you like to should wealthy nations help poor nations essay IFWE Newsletters and Announcements IFWE Blog Daily IFWE Blog Weekly Summary.
Why Should Rich Nations Help The Poor?
, time: 1:41Does 'Fair-Trade' Coffee Help or Hurt Poor Nations?
Sep 21, · It is clear that rich countries has more access of living life appropriatly and should help people who are in need. Even for basic life such as food and housing, wealthly nations are always first in this matter amoung countries in the world | Band: Apr 28, · IELTS Writing Task 2/ IELTS Essay: You should spend about 40 minutes on this task. Some people say that rich nations should help poor countries with their basic needs like food and education while others oppose the idea and argue that the A Modest Proposal For preventing the Children of Poor People From being a Burthen to Their Parents or Country, and For making them Beneficial to the Publick, commonly referred to as A Modest Proposal, is a Juvenalian satirical essay written and published anonymously by Jonathan Swift in The essay suggests that the impoverished Irish might ease their economic troubles by selling their
No comments:
Post a Comment